What to ask a seller before you buy: a checklist by category

In this article
  1. Why the right questions matter
  2. For any item
  3. Sneakers
  4. Watches
  5. Trading cards
  6. Fragrance
  7. Clothing and thrift
  8. How to ask
  9. Reading the answers
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Related guides

Quick answer

Ask every seller about condition, flaws, what's included and how they ship, then ask for the category's proof points: sole, size tag and box label for sneakers; case back, serial and papers for watches; corners and surface for cards; fill level and batch code for fragrance. Specific questions get honest answers.

Why the right questions matter

Most bad purchases come from questions that weren't asked. A genuine seller is happy to answer specific questions, because clear answers mean fewer disputes later. Vague answers, "trust me" or refusing a simple angle are the clearest warning signs you'll get. This checklist covers what to ask for any item, then the proof points for each category.

For any item

  • What flaws does it have, including small ones?
  • What's included: box, tags, papers, receipts, accessories, extra laces or links?
  • Where did you buy it, and do you have the receipt or invoice?
  • How long have you had it, and how was it stored?
  • Can you show it live, next to a note with my username or today's date?
  • How will you pack and ship it, and is there tracking?
  • What happens if it isn't as described?

Sneakers

  • Show the size tag inside the shoe and the box label. Do the style code and size match?
  • Show the outsole and heel. How much wear is there?
  • Any creasing on the toe box? Any yellowing on the midsole or icy sole?
  • Are these the original insoles and laces?
  • Has the pair been cleaned, restored or re-glued?
  • Is the box original to this pair, or a replacement?

Learn what the answers mean in how to spot fake sneakers.

Watches

  • Show the case back and the reference and serial numbers.
  • Is it a full set, with box and papers? Do the papers match the serial?
  • When was it last serviced, and by whom? Are there service papers?
  • Does it keep good time? Show the seconds hand running for a minute.
  • Any replaced parts: dial, hands, crown, crystal, bracelet?
  • Has the case been polished?
  • For automatics: does it hack and hand-wind, if the movement should?

More in checking a used watch on camera.

Trading cards

  • Show the front and back, and all four corners close up.
  • Tilt the card under a light so I can see the surface.
  • Show the edges along the back, where whitening shows.
  • Has it been kept in a sleeve? Will it ship in a sleeve and toploader?
  • For graded cards: show the label and certification number.
  • Is it the English or Japanese version?

Fragrance

  • Hold the bottle against the light to show the fill level.
  • Show the batch code on the box and on the bottle. Do they match?
  • How was it stored? Any time in heat or sunlight?
  • Where was it bought, and is there a receipt?
  • Is it a tester or retail bottle?

More in perfume batch codes.

Clothing and thrift

  • Measurements laid flat: chest (pit to pit), length, shoulders, sleeves.
  • Close-ups of any stains, holes, fading or repairs.
  • The care and size tags.
  • Has it been washed?

How to ask

  • Ask before you pay or bid. In a live show, ask before the timer starts.
  • One question at a time in busy chats.
  • Be specific: "show the heel from behind" works better than "more pics".
  • Ask for live proof for expensive items, not old photos.

Reading the answers

Good signs:

  • Quick, specific answers.
  • Flaws mentioned before you ask.
  • Showing the hard angles without fuss.

Warning signs:

  • "Trust me", "100% original" with no proof.
  • Refusing a simple angle or a live video.
  • Answers that change.
  • Pressure to decide fast.

When the answers don't add up, walk away. There's always another listing.

Frequently asked questions

What's the most important thing to ask a seller?

Ask them to show the specific details that prove authenticity and condition, live, next to your username.

Is it rude to ask for a receipt?

No. Many items are bought without one, but asking is normal, and a receipt adds confidence.

What if the seller won't show something I ask for?

Treat it as a warning sign and walk away.

Should I ask about storage?

Yes, especially for fragrance, sneakers and cards, where heat and humidity affect condition.

How do I ask questions in a live auction?

Ask while the seller is presenting the item, before bidding opens.

General information for buyers and sellers in India, not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws, tax and customs rates and platform policies change, so check the official source before you act.

← All articles