How to read condition descriptions without getting burned
In this article
Quick answer
Condition words like "like new", "excellent" and "9/10" are opinions, not standards, and every seller uses them differently. Treat them as a starting point, then ask for the specific evidence that shows condition in that category. When a description is vague, assume the worse reading until the seller shows you otherwise.
Why condition words mislead
Condition words like "like new", "excellent" and "9/10" are opinions, not standards. Every seller uses them differently, and sellers naturally describe their own items generously. "Excellent" from one seller is "good" from another, and "9/10" sounds precise but isn't measured against anything.
Treat condition words as a starting point. Then ask for the evidence that shows condition in that category, and judge it yourself.
What the common phrases usually mean
| Phrase | Usually means | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Brand new / sealed | Never opened or used | That the seal is factory, not re-wrapped |
| Like new / mint | Used or opened, no visible wear in normal light | Close-ups under bright light |
| Excellent | Light signs of use you have to look for | The areas that wear first |
| Very good | Some visible wear, nothing major | Photos of each flaw |
| Good / gently used | Visible wear, fully working | Overall photos and function |
| Fair / beater | Heavy wear | Whether it's still usable |
| For parts / as is | Not working or badly damaged | Assume the worst |
The words that hide things
- "Minor flaws" without photos.
- "Barely visible", often visible enough to matter.
- "Normal wear", which varies a lot.
- "Pics don't do it justice", which can mean the pictures are flattering.
- "Sold as is", meaning no returns.
Questions that turn vague into clear
- "What flaws can you see, even small ones?"
- "Show me the area that wears first": heel drag on sneakers, the clasp and case edges on watches, corners on cards, fill level on fragrance.
- "Under a bright, white light, please."
- "Is anything replaced, repaired or restored?"
- "How was it stored?"
Category standards worth learning
Some categories have more precise scales that you can use to pin sellers down:
- Sneakers: DS, VNDS, used.
- Watches: unworn, full set, unpolished, service history.
- Cards: NM, LP, MP, HP, and graded scores from 1 to 10.
- Fragrance: fill level and batch code age. See perfume batch codes.
Restoration and repairs
Restored items can look better than their real condition. Common examples:
- Sneakers with re-painted midsoles or whitened soles.
- Watches with polished cases or replaced dials.
- Clothing with repairs.
Restoration isn't bad in itself, but it should be described, and it usually affects price.
Price should match condition
A "like new" item priced as if it's brand new is overpriced. Compare with sold prices for items in the same condition, not with new prices. See how to research a fair price.
A simple rule
When a description is vague, assume the worse reading until the seller shows you otherwise. If the seller won't show you, the answer is usually the worse reading.
For sellers
Clear condition descriptions sell faster and prevent disputes. Use standard terms, list every flaw, and show them on camera. See how to show items on camera.
Frequently asked questions
What does 9/10 condition mean?
It's the seller's opinion, usually meaning light wear. Ask for photos of the areas that wear first.
Is "like new" the same as new?
No. "Like new" means it has been used or opened, even if wear isn't visible.
What's the best way to judge condition online?
Live video under good light, focusing on the parts that wear first in that category.
Should restored items be cheaper?
Often, for collectors. Restoration should always be disclosed.
What does "sold as is" mean?
The seller won't accept returns for condition. Be extra careful.
General information for buyers and sellers in India, not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws, tax and customs rates and platform policies change, so check the official source before you act.